Friday, June 5, 2009

Obama's Cairo Address - Obama Calls For Womens Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence


A credit to Obama - he at least went as far as to call for some improvement in the rights of women in the Middle East. He called for women to be afforded education, the right to work, and the right to wear a hijab. That goes further than the complete absence of any calls by most American feminists. That said, to call Obama's statements on women's rights tepid, if not in many respects harmful by omission, would probably be an overstatement. He wholly ignored any discussion of the key factors subjecting Muslim women to discrimination and violence. And then there was his ridiculous equation of the problems facing Muslim women with the problems faced by women in the West.

The true subjugation of women in Islam begins with institutionalized discrimination in Sharia Law. Beyond that are the insidious practices of honor violence, forced marriage and female genital mutilation. Obama simply glossed over all of this, giving them a patina of acquiesence by his ommission. Instead, he played up his approval of the hijab as an applause line.

Obama failed to make any calls for Sharia law to be evolved so as to allow for equal rights for women. Sharia law is used to discriminate against women in family law and other legal proceedings and to justify violence against women. Sharia allows for a husband to beat his wife. In its most extreme forms, it can lead to results such as last year's Saudi judgment against a woman who was brutally gang raped - that she should be whipped for 200 lashes and then imprisoned for being outside of her home in while unaccompanied by a male guardian.

Besides ignoring Sharia, Obama failed to challenge other true horror for Muslim women - honor violence. As a detailed report on honor violence in Britain made plain, it is a practice both wide spread and insidious:

This study shows that honour killings, domestic violence, forced marriage and FGM are not isolated practices but are instead part of a self-sustaining social system built on ideas of honour and cultural, ethnic and religious superiority. As a result of these ideas, every day around the UK women are being threatened with physical violence, rape, death, mutilation, abduction, drugging, false imprisonment, withdrawal from education and forced marriage by their own families. This is not a one-time problem of first-generation immigrants bringing practices from ‘back home’ to the UK. Instead honour violence is now, to all intents and purposes, an indigenous and self-perpetuating phenomenon . . .

This is a scourge of Islam, both inside and outside the Middle East. If a woman is perceived to have somehow dishonored her family, then relatives may well beat her and perhaps even kill her. Indeed, the poor girl who was gang raped in Saudi Arabia and whose story I linked above was in fact beaten by her brother for the dishonor of being gang-raped. Additionally, Muslim women are prevented from marrying outside of their faith. To do so is often interpreted as an act brining dishonor on the family and any relationship with a man not Islamic is met with violence. How Obama could address women's rights and ignore these grotesque practices is simply beyond comprehension. And by failing to mention them, he gives them a degree of acquiesence where only clear condemnation and scorn are necessary.

Obama also made two comments on the hijab and other clothing women in traditional Muslim societies are required upon pain of punishment to wear. According to Obama:

it is important for Western countries to avoid impeding Muslim citizens from practicing religion as they see fit -- for instance, by dictating what clothes a Muslim woman should wear. We can't disguise hostility towards any religion behind the pretense of liberalism. . . .

I reject the view of some in the West that a woman who chooses to cover her hair is somehow less equal, . . .

Great, except for two things. One, if there is freedom to wear a hijab, or even a burkah, how about the freedom not to wear one? In most Muslim societies, if such coverings are a part of the culture, then they are enforced with violence. Obama pushing this as a woman's right is dangerous, for it will now be an excuse to continue a practice that can be clearly degrading to women. And two, Obama's call for freedom to wear a burkah cannot be going over too well amongst the secularists in Turkey and Tunisia, both of whom have laws banning a woman from covering her head in public buildings or if she is a member of government. Those laws exist to try and keep religion separate from their government. Is Obama that clueless not to realize that?

Lastly, there was Obama's utterly vacuous suggeston of moral and actual equivalence between the mistreatment of women under Islam and the "the struggle for women's equality . . . in many aspects of American life." This is not merely ridiculous, it also has to be disheartening for Muslim women who have never been to the West but who now are being led to believe that their own mistreatment is the norm in America also. Instead of holding up the U.S. as a model for the Islamic world to strive to emulate, Obama lied in a way that will decieve a substantial portion of women in the Middle East and harm their fight for equal rights and freedom from violence.

Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History








Read More...

Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large


I understand those who protest that some countries have [nuclear] weapons that others do not. No single nation should pick and choose which nation holds nuclear weapons. And that's why I strongly reaffirmed America's commitment to seek a world in which no nations hold nuclear weapons.

President Barack Obama, Address in Cairo, June 4, 2009

How many things are suicidally wrong with those statements? One, those statements come perilously close to Obama announcing that he will not use force to stop Iran from getting a nuclear weapon. If we have no right to decide who is able to get a nuclear arsenal, then obviously, in Obamaworld, we have no right to use force to stop such an eventuality. That is troubling indeed, as a nuclear armed Iran presents a danger to the West and to Israel that easily eclipses the threat from the Soviets and China during the Cold War. If you do not know why, Bernard Lewis explains it here.

Two, this is moral equivalency and multiculturalism taken to the very suicidal end of logic and into the realm of fantasy. Every nation is the equal of every other nation, end of discussion? Is there to be no discrimination based on facts and history?

Discrimination is the single most basic of survival skills. You see a snake. Do you give it a wide berth or do you ignore it and walk by. To answer that, you take a look at the shape of its head, its markings and its tail. You may not know the type of snake it is, but looking at those things will immediately tell you weather the snake is deadly or just a friendly forest critter. Bottom line, the ability to discriminate is coextensive with the ability to survive. Is this ice thick enough to hold my weight? Is that branch? Is that man friend or foe? Etc., etc.

We expect our President to be able to discriminate who is a danger to us and who is not. So is Obama capable of considering the fact that Iran is the world's central banker of terrorism? Is it impermissible for Obama consider the assessment of Sec. of Def. Gates, that "everywhere you turn, it is the policy of Iran to foment instability and chaos, no matter the strategic value or cost in the blood of innocents - Christians, Jews and Muslims alike?" Should Obama ignore the mad mullah's unbroken history of the committing or soliciting the most vile terrorism since 1979? Should Obama ignore that Iran's leadership has repeatedly talked of destroying Israel? In Obamaworld, all of these are apparently impermissible bases on which to discriminate between who can have a nuclear weapon and who we should prevent at all costs from attaining one. If that is true, then our chances of survival as well as Israel's just dropped precipitously.

Next, is there anyone in this world over the age of 12 who thinks that Obama's drive toward a nuclear free world is anything other than the most sophomoric of fantasies. I would expect any child, having reached the developmental stage of a 12 year old, to understand that no matter how much Obama may wish it, he cannot put the genie back in the bottle.

And indeed, a world without nuclear weapons is not a safer one. It does not mean any less will be killed in conflicts. Take a look at Japan in World War II. We killed 100,000 plus Japanese with two atomic bombs. The alternative would have been over a million combined U.S. and Japanese casualties had we not used the bombs. Two, how can we be sure that any supposed disarmament is actually bilateral and not unilateral. We would not last long in this world if the only people who had nuclear weapons hidden away were North Korea and Iran.

As to Iran itself, Obama continued his habit of serial apologetics and moral equivalency. Obama apologized to Iran for the U.S. role in a coup that occurred in 1953. He then made a moral equivalency argument, equating that bad act over half a century ago with the countless acts of terrorism and the countless number of innocent lives lost at the hands of the mad mullahs from 1979 through today. Again, Obama shows that he is unable or unwilling to discriminate or make any sort of value judgment. This is not tact, nor is it diplomacy. It is incredibly dangerous because it ignores reality. It is, in fact, weakness writ large.

Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History








Read More...

Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine - A Little Good, A Lot of Outrageousness


Overall, Obama's discussion of Israel and the Palestinian issue during his address at Cairo was troubling indeed. Whatever else may come out of it, one is not improved chances for peace.

Obama's treatment of Israel and the Palestinian issue in his address at Cairo had some high points. One was when Obama called on Hamas to "put an end to violence, recognize past agreements, recognize Israel's right to exist." And no one could ask for stronger words about our commitment to Israel than:

America's strong bonds with Israel are well known. This bond is unbreakable. It is based upon cultural and historical ties, and the recognition that the aspiration for a Jewish homeland is rooted in a tragic history that cannot be denied.

"But on the other hand," that was thereafter followed by the low point of not just Obama's speech, but of any speech on the issue I can recall being given by a Western politician. Not only did Obama fail to put the Palestinian issue into context, he did a Ward Churchill/Noam Chomskey impression, giving the plight of Palestinians the moral equivalence of the Holocaust - the murder of six million Jews by Hitler, with the assistance of at least some Muslims, it might be added. It validated Palestian status as permanent victims on par with the greatest mass murder in history. That was so utterly outrageous as to be unconscionable - and made yet even worse by the fact that it was the leader of the free world uttering it.

As to the larger context, the truth is that the Palestinian issue is important to the Palestinians, but it is grossly inflated as a problem by the rest of the Middle East for their own political and religious purposes. As to the latter, the Wahhabists and Khomeinists in particular see the existence of Israel through the lenses of their triumphalist sects. Their entire legitimacy is predicated on the belief that Islam is the one true religion and that Allah meant for it to conquer the world. How can that happen if Jews have displaced some Muslims on what was once Muslim land. As an aside, the fact that it was Jewish land before that was another fact Obama should also have pointed out, but failed to do so. Instead, he predicated Israel's right to the land on which it sits with the evil of the holocaust - which just happens to be exactly what the Islamic propagandists also claim.

Obama's portrayal of the plight of the Palestinan issue was disingenuous at best, and even beyond the statement of moral equivalence, was framed in such a way as to further validate Palestine's victim status:

For more than 60 years they've endured the pain of dislocation. Many wait in refugee camps in the West Bank, Gaza, and neighboring lands for a life of peace and security that they have never been able to lead. They endure the daily humiliations -- large and small -- that come with occupation. So let there be no doubt: The situation for the Palestinian people is intolerable.

An honest characterization of the Palestinian issue would discuss how the Palestinians have been ruthlessly and cynically exploited by other Middle Eastern countries as a cudgel against Israel. That is a history that began on Israel's first day of independence and continues through today with Iran now acting as the deadly manipulator of Palestinians through its proxy, Hamas. Instead, Obama ignored that reality and painted a picture that puts all of Palestine's problems on Israel. That is not merely ludicrous, it dangerously ignores reality.

But "looking forward," the biggest problem with the picture Obama paints involves what he ignored - the so called "right of return." Israel is a small nation. There are a lot of Palestinians who left Israel when it was formed - some forced out, the majority who left deciding to go of their own accord. At any rate, rather than allow any of these individuals to be accepted into society, the various Middle East countries put them in refugee camps where many remain til today, living in ghettos and kept wholly cut off from the countries where their camps are located. Its insane, but it was done by the various other nations to insure that Palestinians could claim a right to return to the land they once occupied in Israel. To honor the right of return would effectively end Israel, as it would soon become a Muslim majority nation.

If Obama actually wants peace and a two state solution, he needs to address that issue head on. He needs to take a firm stand against a "right of return," and he needs to call on those nations with refugee camps to allow Palestenians to either integrate into their society or move to the West Bank/Gaza at the individual's discretion. Instead, Obama went for applause lines by criticizing Israeli's settlements. Those settlements are not a roadblock to peace. The "right of return" is not just a roadblock to peace, its a recipe for genocide within Israel's borders.

What I found most vacuous was Obama putting the blame on Israel for the quality of life of Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza. This was another outrage. The hard cold truth is that the luckiest Palesinians in the Middle East live inside the borders of Israel. Their quality of life is far better than the quality of life for Palestinians anywhere else in the Middle East. That state of affairs has been brought on by a combination of the utter failure of Palestinians to organize themselves as a civilized society, the cynical manipulation of the Palestinians by the other Middle Eastern countries, and the decision of Hamas et al. in the recent intifada to use freedoms to enter Israel as an opportunity to conduct bombings. The responsibility for Palestinians outside of Israel's borders is on the Palestinians, its on Hamas, its on the PLO, and its on Iran and Syria. Any responsibility that Israel bears is far down on the list. And the fact that Obama ignores that insures that neither the Palestinians nor any of the other players I mentioned will feel compelled to act responsibly in the future.

Another issue was Obama's toothless call for an end to violence against Israel because it costs the Palestinians the "moral high ground." If Obama believes what he said, he is naive in the extreme. Obama and the leadership of Hamas share a different view of what constitutes the moral highground. We value life. Under their salafist interpretation of the Koran, Hamas and the PLO value the slaughter of the non-believers. If Obama wants to stop the violence, he needs to hold Palestine to the same standards as the Israeli's and he needs to apply pressure.

For decades, Palestinians have directed untoward barbarity towards Israel without anyone holding them responsible. Further, they are allowed to spout the most horrendous of propaganda without a word of censure from the West. Shut off all funding for Palestine until Hamas takes its television its children's programming off the air - the shows that are teach hatred and murder from the time the little tykes are weaned from their mother's milk. The next time Hamas claims credit for murdering Israeli civilians, support Israel turning off their power for a week - or two or three. Tell the UN to go to hell the next time they complain that a civilian was killed because a murderer from Hamas was hiding behind the civilian while firing a rocket. If Obama is serious at all about bringing peace to Israel and Palestine, the answer is not going to be found in pressuring Israel over settlements. Hamas and the PLO don't care about the land Israel's settlements sit on, they care about the land Israel sits on. Asking them nicely to take the moral high ground is suicidally naive.

Lastly, there was Obama's vague references to Jerusalem. Obama did not acknowledge Jerusalem as the capital of Israel. Instead, there was this unusual reference - that he looks forward to a day "when Jerusalem is a secure and lasting home for Jews and Christians and Muslims, and a place for all of the children of Abraham to mingle peacefully together . . ." Does that mean that Obama would be open to UN policing of Jerusalem as an international city? Given that the UN is as anti-Semitic as 1939 Germany, I find any hint that Obama sees that as on the table more than a little troubling.

The bottom line is that Obama's remarks on the Israeli Palestinian issue were at best, not helpful, and at worst, damaging indeed to any hopes of peace between Israel and the Palestinians. Where strength is required, we instead were treated to fantasy and weakness.

Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History








Read More...

Thursday, June 4, 2009

Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?


Islam has a proud tradition of tolerance. We see it in the history of Andalusia and Cordoba during the Inquisition. I saw it firsthand as a child in Indonesia, where devout Christians worshiped freely in an overwhelmingly Muslim country. That is the spirit we need today. People in every country should be free to choose and live their faith based upon the persuasion of the mind and the heart and the soul. This tolerance is essential for religion to thrive, but it's being challenged in many different ways.

Among some Muslims, there's a disturbing tendency to measure one's own faith by the rejection of somebody else's faith. The richness of religious diversity must be upheld -- whether it is for Maronites in Lebanon or the Copts in Egypt. . .

President Barack Obama, Address in Cairo, 4 June 2009

President Obama sounded some of the correct notes - in particular his call for freedom of religion, but he fell far short of the type of honesty that is needed to address this problem. And indeed, praising Islam for its history of "tolerance" is akin to praising an alcoholic for his history of sobriety. Islam is, today, the antithesis of "tolerance," and was little better historically. Oh, and a note to our "student of history," via Barcepundit quoted at Soccer Dad: "[B]y the time the Spanish Inquisition was created in 1478, Cordoba has been reconquered from Islamic hands almost 150 years earlier, in 1236." Indeed, see Daled Amos's entire post at Soccer Dad for an in-depth discussion of just how much "tolerance" there was in Andalusia.

To be perfectly clear, the historical "tolerance" of Islam was never something we would recognize today as "tolerance." It did not involve "freedom of religion" as we see that concept. It tolerated non-Muslims as second class citizens, so called "dhimmis," subject to special laws and payment of the jizya - a protection tax payable by non-Muslims. It was more tolerant than medieval Europe of the day - but then again, Christians of the day had reason to be a bit testy with Muslims. It's easier to be magnanimous when you are the victor and are occupying conquered lands. Do recall that it was largely Christian lands that Islam was conquering as part of the greatest imperealistic expansion in history. It was an expansion that began about 700 A.D. and that continued by the sword all the way through 1683 and the Seige of Vienna. It saw Islam conquer all of North Africa, all of the Middle East, Turkey, and various parts of Europe, including areas in Spain and Italy.

There are several aspects of modern Islamic intolerance that are so outrageous that Obama's failure to mention them is nearly criminal. And indeed, topping the list is one with which Obama himself needs to be personally concerned. That is the dogma that it is a sin to convert from Islam and that a person who changes their religion from Islam is an apostate subject to punishment, up to and including death. It is a dogma followed by many of the sects of Islam. Whether or not Obama ever practiced Islam, his father did, and in most Middle Eastern countries, that would make Obama a Muslim at birth. The fact that Obama later chose to practice Christianity makes of him an apostate.

But that is hardly the only outrageous example of this "tolerance" Obama seems to find so laudable. Obama failed to note that the Wahhabi, Salafi, and Deobandi sects in particular interpret the Koran to mean that they can freely murder non-Muslims or enslave them and rape them. For specific references to these doctrines being taught in a Saudi school in Virginia, read the USCIFR report here.

Besides those instances of tolerance, Obama failed to note that: in Pakistan, the charge of blasphemy against the Prophet is being used to steal vast tracts of land from Christians; in Algeria, Christians are being jailed by kangaroo courts for practicing their religion; in Saudi Arabia, there is no freedom to practice any religion but Islam, even in the privacy of one's home; no churches can be built in Turkey; Christians are being systematically persecuted and driven from Palestinian controlled portions of the Holy Land; and Christains and Jews are second class citizens in virtually all Muslim dominated countries. None of that made the speech.

And as to Indonesia about which Obama waxes so eloquently, it, like virtually all of the Islamic world, is being radicalized by a tsunami of wahhabi/salafi Islam being exported on the back of an endless supply of Saudi petrodollars. Obama may have memories of Christians practicing openly in Indonesia, but the reality of today is of "unauthorized" houses of Christian worship being attacked by Islamic radicals.

And then of course there is the attempt by the 57 members of OIC to foist blasphemy laws on the West, cutting off all freedom speech when it comes to Islam. If there is to be freedom of religion - and if Islam is to every actually to grow into "tolerance" - such laws must be absolutely opposed by the West. Obama apparently saw no reason to raise that as yet another example of "tolerance."

Indeed, for Obama to praise Islam for its "tolerance," while failing to acknowledge any of the above is to distort reality out of all recognition. And as always, the failure to face these truths means that they will continue unabated. Indeed, with the vast expansion of Wahhabi Islam, they will actually only grow.

Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History








Read More...

Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History


I am a student of history . . .

. . . [T]hroughout history, Islam has demonstrated through words and deeds the possibilities of religious tolerance and racial equality. I . . . know that Islam has always been a part of America's story. The first nation to recognize my country was Morocco. In signing the Treaty of Tripoli in 1796, our second President, John Adams, wrote, "The United States has in itself no character of enmity against the laws, religion or tranquility of Muslims." . . . And when the first Muslim American was recently elected to Congress, he took the oath to defend our Constitution using the same Holy Koran that one of our Founding Fathers -- Thomas Jefferson -- kept in his personal library.

President Barack Obama, Address From Cairo, 4 June 2009

Obama is a student of history like Karl Marx was a student of the philosophy of Adam Smith. If in fact he ever studied it, he got it all wrong.

Nowhere is this more apparent than in Obama's twisting of our history with the "Islamic world." Obama attempts to portray our relations as friendly from the start, and suggests that there has never been any reason for a clash between Islam and America. This is not mere whitewashing, it is historical revisionism with potentially real and dangerous ramifications.

Let's start with Morocco, an Islamic nation on the north coast of Africa ruled in 1784 by Sultan Muhammad Ben Abdullah. Morocco was not only a nation that engaged in piracy, but it was directly involved in the first war our country fought after Independence - The Barbary Wars. Morocco, in 1784, was the first of the Barbary nations to capture a U.S. merchant vessel, the Betsey, in the Mediterranean and hold its crew hostage. We were then without a navy to protect our merchant ships. Morocco only recognized the U.S. in 1787 because we paid them a huge sum of money as tribute to leave our ships alone. That is hardly the ringing endorsement of friendship and goodwill that Obama seems to be claiming. Indeed, the 1796 treaty to which Obama also refers was one involving all of the "Barbary" nations and was again a futile attempt to end by tribute the pirate jihad being conducted by those nations. As Gerard W. Gawalt of the Library of Congress wrote:

In 1795 alone the United States was forced to pay nearly a million dollars in cash, naval stores, and a frigate to ransom 115 sailors from the dey of Algiers. Annual gifts were settled by treaty on Algiers, Morocco, Tunis, and Tripoli.

And Obama's citation to the words of John Adams is equally disingenuous. True, we had no inherent animus then or now against Islam. But just because we didn't does not mean that the reverse wasn't true. To the contrary, the other half of the story from the 1796 meeting of Thomas Jefferson and John Adams with an envoy from Tripoli was recorded by Jefferson, who wrote:

“. . . [Adams and Jefferson] ‘took the liberty to make some inquiries concerning the ground of the pretensions to make war upon nations who had done them no injury.’ The ambassador [from the Barbary States] replied that it was written in their Koran, that all nations which had not acknowledged the Prophet were sinners, whom it was the right and duty of the faithful to plunder and enslave.” He claimed every one of their guys who was “slain in this warfare was sure to go to paradise."

Directly related to that, and another critical point Obama neglected to mention, is that Thomas Jefferson did not own a Koran because he desired to study Islam for its merits. Jefferson bought and read a Koran because our major foreign policy challenge from 1786 to 1812 was our war with Barbary Pirates who used the Koran as justification for attacking American ships and enslaving American citizens. Jefferson's ownership of a Koran comes under the heading of "know thy enemy."

Obama does neither us nor the Islamic world any favors by twisting history and whitewashing Islam. It only strengthens those who seek to prevent Islam from evolving and it gives the West a distinctly unrealistic view of Islam when the reality is that an ever increasing proportion of Muslims are still today being taught that it is "right and duty of the faithful to plunder and enslave" non-Muslims. It is part of the curriculum being taught in Saudi financed madrassas and schools around the world:

A twelfth-grade Tawhid (monotheism) textbook states that “[m]ajor polytheism makes blood and wealth permissible,” which in Islamic legal terms means that a Muslim can take the life and property of someone believed to be guilty of this alleged transgression with impunity. (Tawhid, Arabic/Sharia, 15) Under the Saudi interpretation of Islam, “major polytheists” include Shi’a and Sufi Muslims, who visit the shrines of their saints to ask for intercession with God on their behalf, as well as Christians, Jews, Hindus, and Buddhists.

To put that into context, our first war in America was with Islamic nations because they believe their Koran justified it. That war came to a close only because the U.S. soon became powerful enough as to threaten those nations with destruction if they continued. Between 1776 and today, it would appear that nothing else has changed in dynamic of that relationship. The Salafists are still teaching that it is a precept of their religion that they can kill and enslave us as part of their faith. That is the reality that Obama needed to address. Not the feel good whitewash and historical revisionism he engaged in during his Cairo speech. People all around the world need to understand the reality. Perhaps then the weight of public opinion might begin to force a change.

Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History


Read More...

This Day In History - 4 June: Solidarnosi, Midway, Nazis In Paris, The Lost Colony and Morbidly Morbid Obesity


Map: Roanoke Island, site of the Lost Colony

781 BC – The first historic solar eclipse is recorded in China.

1039 – Henry III becomes Holy Roman Emperor. Under Henry III the medieval Holy Roman Empire probably attained its greatest power and solidity. Despite his involvment in numerous military campaigns, Henry made religious matters his prime concern and supported monastic reform movements, including the Cluniac order. He branded as simony the customary payments made to the king by new bishops and in 1046 undertook to reform the church. Descending into Italy, he had three rival claimants to the papacy set aside at the synods of Sutri and Rome and was accorded the decisive vote in papal elections. The four German popes named by Henry (including Leo IX) renewed the strength of the papacy, which was to prove the nemesis of his successors.

1584 – Sir Walter Raleigh establishes the first English colony on Roanoke Island, old Virginia (now North Carolina). Between 1585 and 1587, several groups attempted to establish a colony, but either abandoned the settlement or disappeared. leading to one of the great mysteries of history, "The Lost Colony". You will find much more on the "Lost Colony" at the fine blog, Brits At Their Best.

1615 – The great Shogun Tokugawa Ieyasu completes the seige of Osaka Castle with a force of 155,000. With this victory, Tokugawa destroyed the last remaining threat to his rule in Hideyori, the son and rightful heir to Hideyoshi. To learn more about Tokugawa and life in feudal Japan - a country at that time the rightful heir to Sparta in many ways - I recommend the highly readable book, Shogun, by James Clavell. It weaves a bit of fiction through a great deal of fact.

1760 – The Great Upheaval was an act of ethnic cleansing involving the forced population transfer of the Acadian population from Nova Scotia and New Brunswick between 1755 and 1763, ordered by British governor Charles Lawrence and the Nova Scotia Council. It led to the deaths of thousands of Acadians. The policy was extremely controversial, both in Canada and England. New England planters begin arriving on this date to claim land in Nova Scotia, Canada taken from the Acadians. Henry Wadsworth Longfellow published a long, narrative poem about the plight of the Acadians called Evangeline in 1847.

1783 – Man, for the first time, successfully takes flight when the Montgolfier brothers publicly demonstrate their hot air balloon - the montgolfière.

1792 – Captain George Vancouver claims Puget Sound for the Kingdom of Great Britain.

1832: The Great Reform Act redistributes parliamentary seats, giving due weight to Britain's industrial cities and largely ending the corrupt system of "pocket boroughs" whereby rich land owners controlled seats with very small numbers of voters. It was also a part of the drive towards univeral sufferage, though women would not get the vote for several decades.

1876 – An express train called the Transcontinental Express arrives in San Francisco via the First Transcontinental Railroad only 3 days, 11 hours and 39 minutes after having left New York City. The railroad line transecting the U.S. was begun in 1862 at the direction of then President Abraham Lincoln. The thousands of miles of track were built by thousands of labourers, primarily Irish in the East, Mormons in Utah, and Chinese in the West.

1912 – Massachusetts becomes the first state of the United States to set a minimum wage. Minimum wages were first proposed as a way to control the proliferation of sweat shops in manufacturing industries. The sweat shops employed large numbers of women and young workers, paying them highly substandard wages.

1913 – Emily Davison, a suffragette, runs out in front of King George V's horse, at the Epsom Derby. She was trampled and died a few days later, never having regained consciousness. A school teacher, Ms. Davidson had joined the Women's Social and Political Union (WSPU) in 1906, and immediately involved herself in their more militant activities agitating for a woman's right to vote. She was arrested and imprisoned for various offences, including a violent attack on a man she mistook for the Chancellor of the Exchequer. She went on hunger strike in Strangeways Prison and was force-fed. In Holloway prison, she threw herself down an iron staircase as a protest. She landed on wire netting 30 feet below, which saved her; however, she suffered some severe spinal damage. In 1913, she planted a bomb at David Lloyd George's newly built house in Surrey, damaging it severely.

1917 – The first Pulitzer Prizes are awarded: Laura E. Richards, Maude H. Elliott, and Florence Hall receive the first Pulitzer for biography (for Julia Ward Howe). Jean Jules Jusserand receives the first Pulitzer for history for his work With Americans of Past and Present Days. Herbert B. Swope receives the first Pulitzer for journalism for his work for the New York World.

1919 – The U.S. Congress approved the 19th Amendment to the United States Constitution, which guarantees suffrage to women, and sends it to the U.S. states for ratification.

1920 – Hungary, having fought on the wrong side in WWI, lost 71% of its territory and 63% of its population when they were forced to sign the Treaty of Trianon is signed in Paris. It has been a source of bitterness to Hungarians for a century and is to this day known as the Trianon trauma.
1928 – President of the Republic of China Zhang Zuolin was assassinated by Japanese agents. Zhang was one of the power players in the byzantine world of pre-WWII China, where Japan, Chang-ki Shek, and Mao were all vying for power.

1939 – In one of the most despicable events in American history, the SS St. Louis, a ship carrying 963 Jewish refugees, is denied permission to land in Florida after already being turned away from Cuba. Forced to return to Europe, many of its passengers later died in Nazi concentration camps.

1940 – Nazi forces enter the city of Paris, they finish taking control of the city 10 days later.

1942 – The most important naval battle of WWII's Pacific campaign, the Battle of Midway began. Japanese Admiral Chuichi Nagumo ordered a strike on Midway Island by much of the Imperial Japanese navy. American codebreakers were able to determine the date and location of the attack, and the U.S. Navy under Admiral Nimitz set up an ambush. Four Japanese aircraft carriers and a heavy cruiser were sunk in exchange for one American aircraft carrier and a destroyer. The heavy losses, particularly the four fleet carriers and their aircrews, permanently weakened the Imperial Japanese Navy. It was the beginning of the end for Japan.

1944 – General Mark Clark, commander of the U.S. Fifth Army, captured Rome a little over a year into the Italian campaign. Clark's conduct of operations remains controversial, particularly his decision during the Battle of the Winter Line to ignore the orders of British General Harold Alexander, and send the U.S. VI Corps to capture Rome. As a result, he failed to exploit the gap in the German positions that had opened up following the capture of Monte Cassino, allowing a substantial number of German units to escape and reinforce what became the Gothic Line.

1973 – A patent for the ATM is granted to Don Wetzel, Tom Barnes and George Chastain.

1986 – Jonathan Pollard pleads guilty to espionage for selling top secret United States military intelligence to Israel.

1989 – Ali Khamenei is elected the new Supreme Leader of Iran by the Assembly of Experts after the death of Grand Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini. Khamenei had been Khomeini's son in law. He was a mid-level cleric at the time, and was elevated to the position of Grand Ayatollah so that he could assume the position of Supreme Leader. He has very much followed in the footsteps of Khomeini, brutally repressing the people of Iran, waging acts of mayhem and war in all directions, and attempting to spread the velyat-e-faqi of Khomeini throughout the Middle East and the world. He is a man with much blood on his hands.

1989 – The beginning of the end of the Soviet domination of Eastern Europe begins with Solidarnosci's victory in the first free parliamentary elections in post-war Poland. It sparked a succession of peaceful anti-communist revolutions in Eastern Europe, leading to the creation of the so-called Contract Sejm and the Autumn of Nations - a revolutionary wave that swept across Central and Eastern Europe, ending in the overthrow of Soviet-style communist states within the space of a few months.

1998 – Terry Nichols is sentenced to life in prison for his role in the Oklahoma City bombing.

2001 – Gyanendra, the last King of Nepal, ascends to the throne after the massacre in the Royal Palace.

Births

1394 – Philippa of England, queen of Denmark, Norway and Sweden (d. 1430). She was a very efficient ruler. In 1428 she successfully organized the defence of Copenhagen against the Hanseatic League, a heroic feat later recounted by Hans Christian Andersen in Godfather's Picture Book (1868).

1738 – "Mad" King George III of Great Britain. His obstinancy and refusal to treat American colonies as having rights equal to British citizens led directly to the American Revolution and the loss of the thirteen colonies.

1907 – Rosalind Russell, American actress (d. 1976)

1924 – Dennis Weaver, American actor (d. 2006)

1926 – Robert Earl Hughes, American man who became the heaviest known human at an estimated 1,070 lb. When he died at age 32, he was buried in a piano case.

1928 – Dr. Ruth Westheimer, German-born American sex therapist.

Deaths

1039 – Conrad II, Holy Roman Emperor

1798 – Giacomo Casanova, Italian womanizer and writer (b. 1725)

1942 – Reinhard Heydrich, German SS officer in charge of counterintelligence, he was assassinated in an operation planned by the British.


Today is the feast of Saint Petroc of Cornwall, a 6th century Welshman who ministered to Britons in central Britain. He is today one of the patron saints of Cornwall. "The legendary tales surrounding Petroc are exceptionally vivid and imaginative (giving him a second pilgrimage, travels to India, taming wolves) and may represent interpolation from pagan tales."







Read More...

Wednesday, June 3, 2009

Watcher's Council Nominations & An Opening

Each week, the members of the Watcher's Council nominate one of their own posts and a second from outside the Council for consideration by other council members in a contest for best post. The Watcher publishes the results each Friday morning.

There is an opening at the Council if you would like to nominate your blog for the Council. If you go to the Watcher's site, you will find instructions on how to apply on the right-hand sidebar.

Terry Trippany plays the role of Watcher of Weasels. Do visit the Watcher's Site for his theme of the week. This week, its "Six Months and Counting - You Voted For Them" - or to put it another way, caveat emptor, America.

This week's nominations are:

Council Submissions

The Provocateur - Wade Rathke’s Management Council

Joshuapundit - Race Carding Sotomayor

The Glittering Eye - Progressives Aren’t Liberals

Rhymes With Right - Sonia Sotomayor: Free Speech Douchebag

The Colossus of Rhodey - Yet another reason why the News Journal is sinking

Bookworm Room - Murderer or Martyr — the George Tiller killer

Right Truth - Know The Enemy and Destroy Him

Soccer Dad - Where hugo’s huge

Wolf Howling - A Bit Of Honesty From Speaker Pelosi

Mere Rhetoric - Abbas: Olmert Offered Us The West Bank And The Right Of Return, But It Wasn’t Good Enough

Non-Council Submissions

Submitted By: The Provocateur - Real Clear Politics - What’s Keeping Obama Up

Submitted By: Joshuapundit - Michelle Malkin - Crunching the numbers: Dealergate & cronyism continued

Submitted By: The Glittering Eye - Commentary Magazine–Michael J. Totten - The Mother of All Myths

Submitted By: Rhymes With Right - Power Line - Sotomayor’s 60 Percent Reversal Rate

Submitted By: The Colossus of Rhodey - Reason Online - Nostalgianomics

Submitted By: Bookworm Room - Day by Day Cartoon - Obama World

Submitted By: Right Truth - Asia Times Online - Wrong venue for Obama’s Muslim speech

Submitted By: Soccer Dad - Day by Day Cartoon - Amusement Park

Submitted By: Wolf Howling - Megan McArdle - The War On The War On Abortion

Submitted By: Mere Rhetoric - Gawker - Oh, Keith

Read More...

What Does It Mean When A World Class Race Baiter Accuses The Right Of Race Baiting? - A Golden Opportunity


[T]he assault on Sotomayor isn't about her skills as a jurist. This is classic race-based politics from the Republican right.

Jesse Jackson, Sotomayor Critics Just Race-Baiting, Chicago Sun Times, 3 June 2009

American voters say 55 - 36 percent that affirmative action should be abolished, and disagree 71 - 19 percent with Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayer's [sic] ruling in the New Haven firefighters' case, according to a Quinnipiac University poll released today.

Jammie Wearing Fool, quoting from a Quinnipiac poll, 3 June 2009

The irony here is just too good not to sit back and revel in it. So what does it mean when Jesse Jackson, our nation's historical race-baiter in chief, calls Republican criticism of Supreme Court Justice nominee Sonya Sotomayer "race baiting?" Given the incredible clarity of Sotomayer's statements, given that she recently summarily disposed of a reverse racism claim, and given the "historic significance" of Obama's election, it means that we have a golden opportunity to expose and severely retard one of the most destructive political forces our nation has ever seen - the identity politics of the far left.
__________________________________________________

Jesse Jackson and the entire left wing are all playing the race card in response to Republican charges that Sotomayor evinced reverse racism. None are attempting to actually address Sotomayer's words - that by virtue of her sex and nationality, she arrives at "better" judgments than a white man. Nor are they trying to defend those words in light of her summary adjudication of the New Haven Firefighter's case. One simply cannot defend all of that with the even a patina of intellectual honesty on the the grounds that it is anything other than reverse racism. And indeed, their silence on these two points is deafening. Instead, what we get from Jackson and the left - Bob Herbert and Charles Blow being but two other recent examples - are a series of ad hominem attacks on the people who are criticizing Sotomayor. Their abuse of the race card in this instance is just too blatant and obvious.

This actually could be a watershed event. Not because Sotomayor's nomination is going to be derailed - its not and, indeed, it should not be. She should instead be made into a permanent symbol of far left's identity politics and reverse racism. Nothing else will create, in any more stark terms, a picture of the politics of the far left and all that is wrong with it. Further, it does so at a time when, if the above Quinnipiac poll is accurate, tolerance for reverse racism, victim politics and government mandated inequality seems very much to be on the wain. And indeed, there are many intelligent voices providing the grounds for an end to these evils, Victor Davis Hanson and Thomas Sowell being two of the most notable.

The election of Obama was historic and meaningful. Obama expressly held out the promise of a post-racial America, but the reality has shown the opposite. He clearly has no intention of doing away with the victim politics of his base. But no matter - the mere fact of Obama's election has apparently soothed enough white guilt over slavery and the racism that remained in slavery's wake that tolerance for the left's victim politics is approaching a historic nadir. If this is exploited honestly and intelligently, it could well be that Obama's election comes to be both the high water mark of the marxian politics of the far left and, at the same time, the cause of its demise. Oh, but irony is such a wonderfully fickle thing.

At any rate, Republicans should be doing little else during the Sotomayor hearings and the run up to them except discussing the evils of reverse racism and affirmative action. And if they are really smart, they will trot out Victor Davis Hanson and Thomas Sowell and provide them with a national platform to discuss these issues. Indeed, let's see if we can set up a debate on this issue between Hanson and Sowell and, say, Rev. Jeremiah Wright and Jesse Jackson. That's one I'd pay to see.








Read More...

Ramming Speed!!!



. . . Democrats are trying to rush the largest entitlement expansion since LBJ into law with a truncated debate and as little public scrutiny as possible. At this point all they've released are the vaguest "policy options," not concrete specifics. Yet the Senate plans to begin marking up legislation next week, maybe hold a hearing or two, then have something to the floor by the end of the month, votes by the August recess and a bill to the Oval Office by Thanksgiving. On the seventh day, they will rest.


WSJ, Why the Health Care Rush?, 3 June 2009

Health care accounts for a huge chunk - 18% - of our economy. How to reign in health care costs and how best to allocate resources have been contentious topics for years. Obama and the far left want to implement socialized medicine - something that comes with a massive "13 figure" price tag at a time when we are running the largest defecit in history times four and our economy is in the tank. Indeed, the already outrageous level of spending threatens us with inflation on a scale that will make the Jimmy Carter economy look good.

Yet come what may, Obama is bound and determined to force socialized medicine down our throat. Republicans have been completely shut out of the writing of this bill. It is being written in secret by the far left of the Democratic Party. They are seeking to circumvent the normal democratic procedures for passing legislation.

That process is designed to insure that all Americans, as well as our legislators, have a chance to fully understand what it is that is being proposed and to engage in full and free debate. What does it say of Obama that he is attempting to subvert this system. Apparently the same thing this tells us. Obama, having taken power on what clearly were a series of false promises, is now determined to push his real agenda through without regard for democracy. It appears that Obama would have us go from the concept of one person, one vote, to one person, one vote, one time.








Read More...

Road To Ruin


"The U.S. has rising energy needs despite the economic downturn," Prince Turki said. "If you are going to be paying for wind, electric and solar energy equivalents that cost five or 10 times more than it costs to use oil, you are going to price yourself out of the market. You are going to lose whatever competitiveness you have in your products."

Prince Turki al Faisal quoted in Saudi Royal: U.S. Can't Be Energy-Independent, Washington Times, April 27, 2009

Prince Turki is stating the obvious. But, between Obama's push for cap and trade and the breaking of his campaign promise to allow for exploitation of our domestic resources, we are going straight down the road to severe, long term economic problems. The need to exploit these resources is something I posted on at length here. Joshua Pundit points out, in a detailed post, the vast resources at our disposal which sit untouched. I recommend it highly.

Read More...