The administration recently submitted a proposed budget that projects the federal deficit to reach about $1.8 trillion this fiscal year before declining to 1.3 trillion in 2010 and roughly $900 billion in 2011. If your unsure of the economist-esse there, what that means is that we need to get debt under control or face massive inflation and/or massive tax increases - if not both. As Bernanke added: And at some point, you'll hit a point where you'll have to have both very draconian cuts and very large tax increases, which is not something we want. So in order to avoid that outcome down the road, we need to begin now to plan how we're going to get the fiscal situation into a better balance in the medium term. ...: Have you seen any indication at all that Obama has taken heed of those words? Indeed, to the contrary, to add the coup de grâce to the economy, there are Obama's plans to add what amounts to a massive regressive tax on the economy with cap and trade and to add to the mountain of debt with socialized medicine. He has done exactly nothing to stimulate the only engine of our economy - business. There is no fiscal restraint. There are no questions being asked. But the freight train can clearly be heard in the distance. Washington’s “rescue” of GM began because GM is “too big to fail,” and bankruptcy is (well, was) “unthinkable.” Big? GM’s market capitalization, $375.8 million on Wednesday, is about the size of California Pizza Kitchen’s ($340 million) — is it too big to fail? — and one-eleventh that of Harley-Davidson ($4.3 billion). Fail? If GM has not already failed, New Coke was a success. I recall Charles Krauthammer opining on Fox News shortly after Obama was elected, that things wouldn't get that bad under Obama because our economic woes would mean that he didn't have enough money available to implement his "transformation of the economy." Krauthammer did not count on the perfect storm of events in which we find ourselves, and with a President at the helm whose intent to "transform our economy" trumps any consideration of the long term consequences. Krauthammer, to his credit, recognized that reality by December.
That picture about sums up the state of our nation. Put Obama, Pelosi, and Reid in place of the villain. Sub our economy for the damsel in distress. Consider the on-rushing train to be our massive debt, massive borrowing, declining GDP, unemployment, inflation, and Obama's war on business. And quite literally on the heels of those are Obama's massive spending plans that have yet to hit, including cap and trade and socialized medicine. Tack on as the caboose the social security and medicare time bombs waiting in the wings for their cue to take center stage. And all of that does not even consider yet another seeming certainty - a coming massive jump in fuel prices brought on by Obama's war on fossil fuels and his backsliding on promises to allow us to exploit our natural resources and to begin building nuclear plants again. If you are not worried sick about what Obama is doing to our economy, then you are simply not paying attention.
The only thing that does not appear in the above picture is the MSM. The MSM, our supposed watchdog, are asking none of the hard questions. In the past week, for example, instead of asking about the ramifications of Obama's plans to tack yet even more massive spending and borrowing on top of our teetering economy, we have the editor of Newsweek and Chris Matthews speculating on whether Obama is actually a deity. We have masses of people going into unemployment, and instead of stories about how the Obama projections of unemployment were grotesquely off - or how the stimulus isn't stimulating - we instead are treated to stories of how our modern day Marie Antoinette has stayed behind in Paris to enjoy a shopping day at "Bonpoint, a children's clothing store favored by wealthy Parisians and international jet-setters like Sofia Coppola. . . ." The fact that the decision to do that means another massive taxpayer expense - as you can bet they aren't flying home coach - doesn't make it into the story. Let us eat stimulus, eh?
Update: I stand corrected. The AP actually came out with an article today, noting public dissatisfaction with a stimulus bill that isin't stimulating, going so far as to state "Obama Repackages Stimulus Plans With Old Promises."
Interestingly enough, even with this unprecedented sychophancy from the MSM, our Emperor's lack of clothing is nonetheless becoming apparent to the MSM-fed electorate. Recent Gallup polls show the the President finally in the negatives, with 48% to 46% disapproving of how he is handling the economy and 51% to 45% disapproving of the massive federal spending.
Remember when the economy started into its tailspin. The causes were the housing bubble brought about by government enforced lowering of lending standards in the mortgage industry, an utterly broken bond rating system, and mark to market accounting rules. Those all led to massive secondary effects, including the catastrophic failure of derivative securities that were, ironically enough, designed to spread risk. Add to that Niall Ferguson's identification of two prime drivers - improper regulation of bank capitalization and a mistake by the Fed in its control of interest rates.
What if any of those things has Obama addressed? None. Zero. Zip. Nada.
To the contrary, Obama has used the crisis as Keynesian bonanza - and with little or no return to show for it except a national debt that is sufficiently large that we now have to seriously worry about economy crippling secondary effects. No need to take my word for it - take Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke's. This from Mr. Bernanke, via Powerline:
As a consequence of this elevated level of borrowing, the ratio of federal debt held by the public, the nominal GDP, is likely to move up from about 40 percent before the onset of the financial crisis to about 70 percent in 2011. These developments will leave the debt-to-GDP ratio at its highest level since the early 1950s, the years following the massive debt buildup during World War II.
[E]ven as we take steps to address the recession and threats to financial stability, maintaining the confidence of the financial markets requires that we, as a nation, begin planning now for the restoration of fiscal balance. Prompt attention to questions of fiscal sustainability is particularly critical because of the coming budgetary and economic challenges associated with the retirement of the baby boom generation and continued increases in medical costs. ... With the ratio of debt to GDP already elevated, we will not be able to continue borrowing indefinitely to meet these demands.
In particular, over the longer term, achieving fiscal sustainability -- defined, for example, as a situation in which the ratios of government debt and interest payments to GDP are stable or declining, and tax rates are not so high as to impede economic growth -- requires that spending and budget deficits be well controlled.
The last time our government tried to lift us out of an economic crisis of this proportion with massive spending was during the depression, and it didn't work then either. And unlike FDR, we have no WWII waiting in the wings to finally pull us out of this ever deepening economic crisis.
Instead of stimulating the private sector by reducing an already confiscatory corporate tax and providing tax breaks to the actual tax payers - two acts which have proven effective every time they have been tried - Obama has borrowed and spent us into penury. It was Obama who told us that if we just gave him what we wanted, then unemployment wouldn't rise over 8%. Well . . .
Unemployment is rising - now to 9.4% - far beyond where Obama promised us if we would just pass his stimulus package in 48 hours without reading it. And indeed, just today, Obama announced plans to "create 600,000" jobs by speeding up stimulus spending. That may sound nice, but we are obviously losing jobs exponentially faster than the stimulus is creating them and, most importantly, none of these stimulus jobs come with any type of permenance. These aren't private sector jobs where you invest in an employee expecting that the employee will help you become more profitable long-term. The stimulus jobs aren't permenant. They are jobs to do a certain function that ends at one of two points - when the particular task ends or the public funding ends. It is smoke and mirrors of the worst kind. Indeed, no one more accurately sums up this insanity than Mark Steyn in his article of two weeks ago, What Are We Stimulating. May the funds be with you indeed. [Update: As pointed out by ex-dissident in the comments, to add to that, do see Michelle Malkin's post on the topic of 600,000 new jobs. It's an eye opener.]
Meanwhile, in the real world of business, the U.S. has the second highest corporate tax rates in the Western world. Its not confiscatory enough for Obama, apparently. Several days ago, there were the comments from the Microsoft CEO Steven Balmer that, if Obama in fact gets his plans through to tax overseas profits under the rubric of "closing a loophole," the CEO would move many of its employees overseas. Perhaps Obama should consult Maryland as to the effective tax rate on millionaires who decide they don't want to pay confiscatory taxes. That tax rate is zero, regardless of what the tax code may say.
Then there is Obama's class warrior plan to set limits on payments to private sector employees in the banking and financial industries - even businesses that have not accepted a dime of bailout money. This is the socialist / leftist solution to all things - more regulation. Bottom line, market forces will take care of private sector compensation if it does not make economic sense. It happens when poorly run businesses fail. The government's plan to control compensation will drive the best and brightest into the overseas competitors of our financial sector or out of the financial sector entirely. We will see a wilting of this key area of our economy. Oh, and by the way, its been done before. The year, 1931. As Villagers With Torches points out, it accomplished absolutely nothing in terms of lifting us out of the depression.
And then to top off all of the economic good news, we learned a few days ago that Obama is relying on a 31 year old grossly unqualified political appointee to drive the government's programs as regards GM and Chrysler. Is it any wonder that we soon thereafter find out that the Chrysler-Fiat deal was foisted on Chrysler with no real knowledge or investigation of Fiat? Indeed, this has all the earmarks of a superficially "good idea" dreamed up by a bunch of amateurs who have then pushed it through without bothering to check whether it was a "good idea" in reality. Both Chrysler and GM are now on life support. The government has stiffed the people who provided capital to these companies in favor of patronizing the UAW - itself one of the prime causes of the GM / Chrysler downfall. Our government, with the UAW as a junior partner/parasite, now runs GM and Chrysler. As George Will writes:
The administration is determined to prop up GM as a jobs program for the UAW and Midwestern states rich in electoral votes. This frenzy will intensify as the administration’s decisions deepen the debacle.
The train is coming. It couldn't be any clearer. Meanwhile, Obama is tightening the ropes tying us to the tracks. And the MSM, they're too involved in praising Obama's god-like skills with knots to ask any questions about that annoying whistle getting ever louder in the background.
Monday, June 8, 2009
Of Villains, The Economy, & On-Rushing Trains
Posted by
GW
at
Monday, June 08, 2009
3
comments
Labels: cap and trade, economy, GDP, michelle obama, MSM, obama, stimulus, taxation, unemployment
Watcher's Council Results & An Opening
Each week, the Watcher's Council holds a contest for best post. The Council members submit a post they have written and one post by someone outside the Council for consideration. The Watcher tallies the votes and announces the winners each Friday.
There is an opening on the Council. If you would care to submit your blog for consideration, please visit the Watcher's site. You will find instructions on the right side bar for applying to join the Council.
On to the results. This week's winners were:
Coming in first place in a runaway was Mere Rhetoric exceptional post, Abbas: Olmert Offered Us The West Bank And The Right Of Return, But It Wasn’t Good Enough. Way down the list coming in second place was my post, A Bit Of Honesty From Speaker Pelosi, dealing with how a variety of leftist groups intend to use control over carbon emissions to vastly expand government's role in our life. There were a number of ties at third place, including The Provocateur's Wade Rathke’s Management Council, The Colossus of Rhodey's Yet another reason why the News Journal is sinking, Bookworm Room's Murderer or Martyr — the George Tiller killer, and lastly, Joshuapundit's Race Carding Sotomayor.
In the Non-Council competion, coming in first place in a runaway was Michael J. Totten's The Mother of All Myths, accurately to my mind pointing out that Salafi Islam is the problem in the Middle East, not the Israeli Palestinian issue. Coming in second place, in a three way tie, was the Day by Day Cartoon Amusement Park (do see this one), Asia Times Online's Wrong venue for Obama’s Muslim speech, and Megan McArdle's The War On The War On Abortion. Tie for third place were Reason Online's Nostalgianomics and Gawker's Oh, Keith.
Posted by
GW
at
Monday, June 08, 2009
0
comments
Labels: Watcher of Weasels, Watcher's Council
This Day In History - 8 June: The Viking Age Begins at Lindisfarne, Muhammad and England's Black Prince Die

793 - Vikings from Norway landed at Lindisfarne, sacking the abbey and slaughtering the inhabitants. The entry for the year 793 in the Anglo-Saxon Chronicle is:
This year came dreadful fore-warnings over the land of the Northumbrians, terrifying the people most woefully: these were immense sheets of light rushing through the air, and whirlwinds, and fiery, dragons flying across the firmament. These tremendous tokens were soon followed by a great famine: and not long after . . . the harrowing inroads of heathen men made lamentable havoc in the church of God in Holy-island, by rapine and slaughter.
It marked the start of the Viking Age that would span four centuries and greatly shape Europe, from Russia to Ireland. Indeed, the Normans who would eventually conquer England were Vikings who had been ceded Normandy by the French King as tribute.
1191 – King Richard CÅ“ur de Lion (Richard The Lionheart) arrives in Acre thus beginning his crusade. He would succeed in defeating Saladin at Acre, but eventually had to return from the Crusades as his brother John and the French King Phillip were plotting against him in his absence.
1405 – Richard le Scrope, Archbishop of York and Thomas Mowbray, Earl of Norfolk, are executed in York on Henry IV's orders after the two had led a revolt against him.
1776 – American attacks on an advancing column of British at Battle of Trois-Rivières in Quebec were driven back. It marked the end of American attempts to force the British out of Quebec.
1783 – The volcano Laki, in Iceland, begins an eight-month eruption which kills over 9,000 people and starts a seven-year famine.
1789 – James Madison introduces 12 proposed amendments to the United States Constitution in the United States House of Representatives; 10 of them are ratified by the state legislatures and become the Bill of Rights. The two amendments not ratified concerned apportionment of representatives and pay for Congressmen.
1856 – The community of Pitcairn Islands and descendants of the mutineers of the HMS Bounty consisting of 194 people arrived on the Morayshire at Norfolk Island Commencing the Third Settlement of the Island.
1906 – Theodore Roosevelt signs the Antiquities Act into law, authorizing the President, by Executive Order, to restrict the use of public land with historical or conservation value.
1912 – Carl Laemmle incorporates Universal Pictures.
1941 – Britain and Free French forces invade Vichy controlled Syria and Lebanon.
1942 – Japanese imperial submarines I-21 and I-24 shell the Australian cities of Sydney and Newcastle.
1949 – Celebrities Helen Keller, Dorothy Parker, Danny Kaye, Fredric March, John Garfield, Paul Muni and Edward G. Robinson are named in an FBI report as Communist Party members.
1953 – The United States Supreme Court rules that Washington, D.C. restaurants could not refuse to serve black patrons.
1967 – In a friendly fire incident during the Six Days War, Israeli jets attacked the USS Liberty, killing 34 and wounding 171.
1968 – James Earl Ray is arrested for the murder of Martin Luther King, Jr. .
1984 – Homosexuality is declared legal in the Australia state of New South Wales
1987 – New Zealand's Labour government establishes a national nuclear-free zone under the New Zealand Nuclear Free Zone, Disarmament, and Arms Control Act 1987. One must truly appreciate the holier than thou moralism of all on the left. Fortunately for NZ's Labour Party, its country's defense was guaranteed by adults who could not afford the luxury taking the moral highground.
Births
1810 – Robert Schumann, German composer (d. 1856)
1867 – Frank Lloyd Wright, American architect (d. 1959)
1872 – Jan Frans De Boever, Belgian painter (d. 1949)
1921 – Suharto, President of Indonesia (d. 2008)
1925 – Barbara Bush, First Lady of the United States
1925 – Eddie Gaedel, American baseball player (d. 1961)
Deaths
218 – Macrinus, Roman Emperor. He was an Algerian and the first Emperor not a member of the Senate. His reign did not last long and he fell to court intrigues.
632 – Muhammad, Prophet of Islam died after having united Arabia and captured Mecca and Medina. In the years after his death, the Koran would be written and his followers would be divided between Sunni and Shia, depending on whom they believed was the rightful heir to the Caliphate.
1042 – Harthacanute, King of Denmark and England. He was a deeply unpopular king who heavilly taxed his subjects. The Anglo-Saxon Chronicle gives a dismal assessment of him: "He never accomplished anything kingly for as long as he ruled." It is believed that it was his heavy taxation that led Lady Godiva to engage in her famous protest ride.
1376 – Edward, the Black Prince, son of Edward III of England and a brilliant military commander, including in his long list of campaigns Crécy and Poitiers. He is buried in Canterbury Cathedral where his sword, shield and mail are on display.
1795 – King Louis XVII of France - he was the son of Louis XVI but was never crowned. He was imprisoned along with his family during the French Revolution. After his father and mother were executed, he was kept in prison and brutalized until, at the age of ten, he died.
1809 – Thomas Paine, American revolutionary and writer (b. 1737)
1845 – Andrew Jackson, 7th President of the United States (b. 1767)
1874 – Cochise, Apache leader
1956 – Marie Laurencin, French painter (b. 1883)
1970 – Abraham Maslow, American psychologist (b. 1908)
Holidays and observances
Roman Empire – second day of the Vestalia in honor of Vesta. Her temple was cared for by the Vestal Virgins who swore to remain chaste for 30 years upon pain of death by fire. Vesta was the goddess of fire and the hearth at the centre of atrium and home.
Posted by
GW
at
Monday, June 08, 2009
3
comments
Labels: anglo-saxon chronichle, Black Prince, lindisfarne, Muhammad, Richard the Lionheart, Saladin, Third Crusade, Vikings
Sunday, June 7, 2009
Labour's "Long, Dark Night Of Humiliation" - Britain & Europe Swing Right

Labour did not just lose the latest 4 June EU Parliament elections, they got toasted. According to the Guardian:
. . . Labour trailed humiliatingly behind UKIP in the European elections and was expected to garner about 16% or 17% of the vote, its lowest share since the First World War and below the party's worst expectations.
During a dramatic night of unremitting gloom for Downing Street, the Tories appeared to have pulled more than 10 points ahead of Labour, with UKIP in second. The BNP also secured its first significant wins in British politics when its leader Nick Griffin became an MEP in the north-west, and Andrew Brons – a former leader of the National Front - won in Yorkshire and Humber.
Read the entire article. The gains by the BNP in particular have the left spitting blood. The British left did all they could to demonize the BNP, including trotting out the Archbishop of Canterbury, the odious Rowan Williams, to rail against voting for the BNP. All to no avail, it seems, as the Daily Mail reports: "The triumph for the [BNP] neo-fascist party, which will now send two MEPs to Brussels - including its leader Nick Griffin - sent shockwaves through Westminster . . ."
I do not know if its fair to characterize today's BNP as a "neo-facist" party, but I do know that they seem to be the only party speaking out on taboo issues that threaten the very fabric of the UK, not the least of which is immigration. They are tapping into a lot of angst among the rank and file that the Tory Party, which has sought to emulate the Labour Party in so many ways, simply is not. I think the best possible thing for British politics would be for the BNP to have a stand on the national stage. So long as they don't evince overt racism, they may be able to spark a true national debate free of PC restrictions on such things as freedom of speech, health and safety, multiculturalism, nationalism, and immigration - all areas where socialist policies have done immense damage to the fabric of British life.
Indeed, having watched the socialists in Labour deconstruct British society and attack Christianity over the past decade and then turn Britain into a province of the EU without a vote of the British electorate, its nice to see the pendulum swing and swing hard. Certainly a good portion of this vote was a reaction to the scandal over MP expenses. But it was part of a greater movement all across Europe that saw big gains by right and center-right parties, including most notably Geert Wilder's anti-EU, anti-immigration party which "shot to second place behind the ruling Christian Democrats by taking 17 per cent of the vote in the Netherlands." Wilders is outspoken in his stance against the predations of Islamists throughout Europe and is perhaps best known for his production of the movie short, Fitna (see here).
This also from the above-linked Guardian article:
Labour's European meltdown was amplified on a continental scale last night as the centre-left across the EU suffered defeats despite an economic climate from which it should profit. The most significant outcome was in Germany, the EU's biggest member country, where the Social Democrats (SPD) came in 17 points behind Chancellor Angela Merkel's Christian Democrats and their Bavarian CSU ally.
In France, and Italy the centre-right also scored victories while Spain's socialist government lost to the conservatives.
Now if we can only get our own socialist left out of power, perhaps there is yet a chance for Western Civilization to survive.
Posted by
GW
at
Sunday, June 07, 2009
2
comments
Labels: BNP, EU, EU Parliament, Geert Wilders, Labour, Tory, UKIP
Good News Out Of Lebanon
Congratulations to Lebanon, congratulations to democracy, congratulations to freedom. The Lebanese have proved today their commitment to freedom and democracy. There are no winners and losers in this election, the only winner is democracy and the biggest winner is Lebanon.
Saad Al-Hariri, Leader of the Anti-Syrian Coalition 'March 14,' announcing victory in the 7 June 2009 election.
Despite the best efforts of Iran to turn the Lebanese election in favor of its proxy, Hezbollah, the anti-Syrian coalition known as "March 14," defeated Hezbollah and its allies in Lebanon's parliamentary election on Sunday. This from Ya Libnan:
. . . OTV, the television station of one of Hezbollah's key Christian allies, former army chief Michel Aoun, conceded that the party's candidates who challenged pro-Western competitors in several Christian districts had been defeated, preventing a victory for the Hezbollah coalition. But Aoun was able to hang on to his representation in other districts.
Lebanese Broadcasting Corporation, a leading private Christian TV station, projected the pro-Western coalition to win 68 seats in the next parliament, with 57 for Hezbollah and its allies and three for independents.
That would almost replicate the deadlock that existed in the outgoing parliament, in which the pro-Western bloc had 70 seats and an alliance of Hezbollah and other Shiite and Christian factions had 58.
The leader of the largest bloc in the pro-Western coalition, Saad Hariri, said early Monday in a televised speech that he extends his hand to the losing side "to work together and seriously for the sake of Lebanon." He urged supporters to celebrate without provoking opponents.
But despite the conciliatory tone, Lebanon was at risk of sliding again into a political crisis over formation of the next government similar to the one that buffeted the country for most of the last four years.
Hezbollah had veto power in Siniora's Cabinet for the last year, which it won after provoking the worst street clashes since the 1975-1990 civil war. The pro-Western coalition had vowed not to give Hezbollah and its allies a blocking minority in the new government if they won.
The battle in Christian districts was the decisive factor. Lebanese generally vote along sectarian and family loyalties, with seats for Sunnis and Shiites in the half-Christian, half-Muslim, 128-member parliament already locked up even before the voting started.
Christians in the pro-Western coalition warned that Hezbollah would bring the influence of Shiite Iran to Lebanon. The Maronite Catholic Church made a last-minute appeal, warning that Lebanon as a state and its Arab identity were threatened, a clear reference to Hezbollah and its Persian backer, Iran.
Sunnis were also driven to vote for the pro-Western coalition to get back at Shiite Hezbollah gunmen for seizing the streets a year ago in Beirut from pro-government supporters.
Some 3.2 million people out of a population of 4 million were eligible to vote, and the interior minister said after polls closed that the turnout nationwide was about 52.3 percent, an increase over the 2005 figure of 45.8 percent. . . .
Read the entire article. This is good news indeed.
Posted by
GW
at
Sunday, June 07, 2009
0
comments
Labels: election, Hariri, Hezbollah, Iran, Lebanon, March 14
Saturday, June 6, 2009
D Day, 6 June 1944

Today is the 65th anniversary of the D-Day landings at Normandy, France. I had wanted to do a long post on this, but unfortunately got so tied up pulling apart the President's Cairo address that I ran out of time.
I've been fortunate to know a few people who were involved in the D-Day landings. One I knew was in the initial assault on Omaha Beach. I asked him about it once. He said that he was never so afraid before or since in his life. He remembers getting off the landing craft but only vaguely recalls fighting his way across the beach. All of his friends were killed and by the time he managed to get by the last German position to his front. he was alone and low on ammo. When he took a moment to think, some of the adrennilaine wore off and he realized he was scared to the point of death. He saw a barn in the distance, decided there was no force on earth that would make him go back on the beach, and then ran like hell for the barn. He said he got inside and spent the next 48 hours hiding in there, until he saw some other U.S. soldiers walk by. He said that one of the toughest decisions of his life was whether or not to try and stay in the barn for the remainder of the war.
At any rate, you can find some excellent D-Day posts around the web.
- Righwing Nuthouse: A Word About Courage.
- Powerline: The Ordeal Of Omaha Beach
- Small Unit Actions: 2nd Ranger Batt. at Pointe Du Hoc
- Thunder Run: Utah Beach
- Flopping Aces: D-Day Footage With Veteran's Narration
- Flopping Aces: Reagan's D-Day Speech
- Flopping Aces: FDR's D-Day Prayer
- Brits At Their Best: D-Day
- Joshua Pundit: Loyalty & Love - D-Day 65 Years Later
- Right Truth: D-Day Remembered
- Blue Crab Boulevard: A Flame Bright Beyond Common Understanding . . .
- Stop The ACLU - Operations Neptune and Overlord 65 years later
- Hot Air: The Day The West Freed Itself From Tyranny
And from the "Cynical Humor On D-Day" Dept., do see
- TNOY: Obama Offers French Profound Apology For D-Day
- No Oil For Pacifists: D-Day Causes A Resumption Of The French Anglo Wars
Posted by
GW
at
Saturday, June 06, 2009
2
comments
Labels: 2nd ranger battalion, D-day, Normandy, obama, omaha beach, pointe du hoc, Reagan, utah beach
Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got

I held high hopes for President Obama and his speech from Cairo to the Muslim world. With his Islamic background, President Obama was uniquely positioned to effectively speak some hard truths to the Muslim world. He was uniquely qualified to use the bully pulpit to call for much needed reforms in Islam. And he was uniquely qualified to educate both the Islamic world and the rest of us on the reality at the heart of Muslim violence. My hope was that he would find a way to do those things without being insulting and while expressing an optimistic vision of what was possible.
That is not what President Obama did. He did not merely fail to accomplish what was needed in his speech, but in many ways, he damaged our interests. Indeed, for what good he did with his strong statement on our "unbreakable" bonds with Israel and his mention of women's rights, his pronouncements and omissions on virtually all other critical issues can only serve to make matters worse.
Obama at one point said that “we must face the hard issues.” The reality is that his speech was a study in ignoring those issues, or worse, being less than honest about them. He also made repeated, unforgivable statements of moral equivalency that have the effect of allowing guilty parties to excuse their own misconduct and make any needed change in their conduct less likely. Making such statements of moral equivalency - for example, equating the plight of the Palestinians to the holocaust or equating the mistreatment of women in Muslim society with the problems women face in American society - is counterproductive and appears as weakness.
To be more specific, below are brief summaries of the salient points from my more detailed posts on each issue:
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to speak the hard truth to the Muslim world about the nature of its problems, he instead merely restated the excuses for those problems common throughout the Muslim world - that modernity is incompatible with Islam and that the causes of the backwardness of Islamic states are external.
Where Obama needed to encourage Muslims to take responsibility for the state of their nations and the evolution of their religion, he was silent.
Where Obama needed to defend freedom of speech and encourage critical thinking about Islam in the Muslim world, he said not a word.
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to promote democracy throughout the Middle East, he instead mouthed the words of multiculturalism and moral equivalence, announcing that the U.S. did not have the moral authority to impose governmental structures on others, marking a return to the failed 'real politik' policies of the past.
Where Obama needed to use Iraq as an example of what was possible in terms of democracy, freedom of speech, and equality, he instead spoke of it as an embarresment and a wrong to be quickly forgotten.
Where Obama needed to announce that he would protect Iraq's nascent democracy, Obama instead announced proudly that he will leave Iraq to its own devices – and ultimately, to the predations of its voracious neighbor.
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to address women's rights robustly, he did so tepidly.
Where Obama needed to honestly address the subjugation of women in the Middle East and the violence directed towards them, he instead ridiculously equated their plight with that of women in the West.
Where Obama needed to discuss and condemn the institutionalized subjugation of women by Sharia law, Obama was silent.
Where Obama needed to use the bully pulpit to condemn honor violence for the evil that it is, Obama said not a word.
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to take a bold stand against nuclear proliferation, Obama mouthed the suicidally inane argument that no nation should dictate which other nations may or may not acquire nuclear weapons.
Where Obama needed to speak to the Muslim world about the dangers of Iran's nuclear weapons program and the need for concerted effort, instead Obama spoke about the utter fantasy of a world without nuclear weapons.
Where Obama need to condemn Iran's endless acts of terrorism and their deadly meddling in Lebanon, Gaza, Iraq, Sudan, the UAE, Bahrain and Azerbaijan, Obama instead announced a moral equivalence between the single act of the U.S. to engineer a coup against the unelected Iranian PM Mohammed Mosaddeq over half a century ago and the mountain of evil acts and the oceans of blood accumulated by Iran's theocrats since 1979.
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to make a strong and clear statement of our support for Israel, he did.
Where Obama needed to call on Hamas to end violence, recognize past agreements, and recognize Israel's right to exist, he did.
Where Obama needed to hold the Palestinians responsible for building a functional society, he instead blamed Israel for their current state and detestably gave moral equivalence to the plight of Palestinians with the holocaust.
Where Obama should have been pointing out the ramifications of the fact that Palestinians inside Israel enjoy a far higher quality of life than anywhere else in the Middle East, he instead stayed silent on the ill treatment and manipulation of Palestinians by all of the other Middle East countries.
Where Obama needed to make a clear statement that the “plans for peace” put forth by the Arabs are ill disguised roadmaps to the destruction of Israel, he instead identified Israeli settlements as being the major roadblock to peace.
Where Obama needed to quash once and for all the canard of a “right of return” and call upon all Middle East countries to allow Palestinians to integrate into the countries in which they now live, he was silent.
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
****************************************************************
Where Obama needed to be honest with Islam and the world about the intolerance of Islam and condemn in no uncertain terms the practice of harming or killing any who convert from the Muslim faith, Obama ignored this while claiming Islam had a history of "tolerance."
Where Obama should have condemned in no uncertain terms the Salafi dogma taught around the world that it is permissible for a Muslim to slaughter those of other religions and to plunder their possessions, Obama was silent.
Where Obama should have spoken against the practice in Pakistan of using charges of blasphemy against the Prophet to justify the disenfranchisement of Christians and theft of their lands, Obama said not a word.
Where Obama should have chastised Algeria for jailing Christians for practicing their religion, he was silent.
Where Obama should have railed against Turkey for their refusal to allow any churches to be built, he instead ignored it.
Where Obama should have condemned the systematic persecution of Christians by Palestinian Muslims in Gaza, the West Bank and Jerusalem, his silence was deafening.
Where Obama should have pointed out that non-Muslims of whatever stripe are treated as second class citizens in all Muslim countries, he was silent.
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
****************************************************************
Where Obama should have been honest about our history with the Islamic world, Obama gave a completely false picture of the nature of the relationship between the U.S. and Islam from the earliest days of our country.
Where Obama pointed out that Morocco was the first country to recognize America, he failed to mention that the recognition came as part of a deal that saw America pay a huge sum of money to ransom a U.S. merchant ship and crew that Morocco had pirated, Obama delibertely gave a false impression by neglecting to mention that detail.
Where Obama should have pointed out that the same philosophy used by the Barbary Pirates to justify war against America, that it is “the right and duty of the faithful to plunder and enslave” non-Muslims, is in fact being taught still today in Saudi Salafi schools and madrassas throughout the world, Obama stayed silent.
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History
****************************************************************
Obama's speech in Cairo was a golden opportunity for our nation, the Muslim World, and the world as a whole. We bear no inherent animus towards Islam. And indeed, our world would be a better and richer one with good and peaceful relationships between Islam and other religions, between the Middle East and the U.S. But there are enough dysfunctional aspects of Islam today that such an eventuality will never be possible unless changes happen. Obama had a chance to be open and honest about all of this in Cairo. He failed. He failed us, and he failed his audience in the Muslim world.
Update: In my points above, I failed to note that Obama needed to also address the mistreatment/execution of gays. Unfortunately, as Gay Patriot points out, not only was Obama silent on that point, but so have been all the left-wing gay groups in the U.S.
Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History
Posted by
GW
at
Saturday, June 06, 2009
0
comments
Labels: Cairo, gay rights, Gaza, Hamas, honor violence, Iran, Israel, moral equivalency, multiculturalism, nuclear, obama, palestine, Salafi, Wahhabi, women's rights
Friday, June 5, 2009
Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
The relationship between Islam and the West includes centuries of coexistence and cooperation, but also conflict and religious wars. More recently, tension has been fed by colonialism that denied rights and opportunities to many Muslims, and a Cold War in which Muslim-majority countries were too often treated as proxies without regard to their own aspirations. Moreover, the sweeping change brought by modernity and globalization led many Muslims to view the West as hostile to the traditions of Islam.
Violent extremists have exploited these tensions in a small but potent minority of Muslims. . . .
President Barack Obama, Cairo Address, 4 June 2009
What we needed from the leader of the free world was honesty with both the Muslim world and with us. What we were treated to instead were apologetics and dissimulation about the existential problems facing the Muslim world. One, Obama needed to honestly identify the source of violence arising out of Islam. He did not. Two, there is a war raging for the heart and soul of Islam. It is a war between those who would see their religion evolve and those who wish to see it stay static in the tribal dogma of 7th century Arabia and the 12th century philosophy of ibn Tamiyah. Obama needed to acknowledge this war of ideas and he needed to show support for the reformers. He did neither.
Obama claimed that "violent extremists" from a "small minority" of Muslims are at the heart of violence arising out of the Islamic world. That is a gross distortion of the truth and an incredibly dangerous one - if one cannot identify the source of violence, then one cannot act to stop it.
The engines of Muslim violence are the dogma of Wahhabi/Salafi Islam and its variants, including Khomeinist Shia'ism:
Wahhabi / Salafi Islam, [has been] exported from Saudi Arabia to all four corners of the world with billions in petrodollars to become the dominant form of Islam in the West, [and is vying to replace all other forms of Sunni Islam in the Muslim world]. According to Dr. Tawfiq Hamid, a former Salafi terrorist and member of Ayman al Zawahiri’s Jamaah Islamiyah, their faith in the medieval dogma of Wahhabi / Salafi / Deobandi Islam is what drives their violence:
The goal of Salafi Islam is "complete Islamic dominance." Salafi dogma holds that the duty of every Muslim is to wage "jihad against non-Muslims and subdue them to Shari'a - the duty of every true Muslim . . . [It is] to engage in war against the infidels, the enemies of Allah.
And as Zuhdi Jasser explains, terrorism is far more than a mere anomaly as . . . [some are] suggesting:
[Citizens] need to understand that this is not a conflict against a tactic but rather a common ideology which utilizes a radical interpretation of Islam and is a natural off-shoot from political Islam.
NRO Interview of M. Zhudi Jasser
And then there is this warning from Tawfiq Hamdid, explaining why it is so important to identify the source of this evil, not just for the protection of the West, but equally for the protecton of Muslims:
The civilized world ought to recognize the immense danger that Salafi Islam poses; it must become informed, courageous and united if it is to protect both a generation of young Muslims and the rest of humanity from the disastrous consequences of this militant ideology.
Tawfiq Hamid. See also my posts here, here and here. Obama's refusal to face this issue head on and speak the truth to the Muslim world has a three fold effect. One, it gives cover to Wahhabism to continue its growing march free from criticism of its vile tenets, among which include that is morally permissible, if not required, to slaughter non-Muslims and to appropriate their property. Two, it demonstrates a complete lack of support for those who fight against this scourge in the Muslim world. And three, it allows Muslims to deny responsiblity for their plight and their failure to reform their religion.
As to the war of ideas raging in Islam today, it is a war being waged by the extremely powerful and well funded Salafi/Wahhabi sects and the Khomeinist variant of Shia'ism against the other sects of Islam and against individuals committed to reform of their religion. Among their number are Zuhdi Jasser, Tawfiq Hamid, Ibn Warraq, Dr. Taj Hargey and the Center for Islamic Pluralism. They war for the heart and soul of Islam. It is a war whose outcome will be every bit as important for the future of the world as was the outcome of World War II. And to remain neutral in this war would be no different than if the U.S. had remained neutral in the European theatre of World War II, allowing Hitler to conquer all of Europe. Yet Obama, with his refusal to even acknowledge this issue in his Cairo address, has chosen precisely that path.
One of the most recent salvos in that war of ideas came from inside the United Nations. Wahhabists and Khomeinists have been agitating for years to impose blasphemey laws on the West. The result of such laws would be to make it inevitable that Salafi and Khomeinist Islam would triumph in the war of ideas. It would mean that these deeply dangerous ideologies would be able to spread through the West hidden from criticism by West's own criminal laws. In August, 2008, the "Human Rights Council at the United Nations . . . banned any criticism regarding Sharia Law and human rights in the Islamic World." And now, the OIC is pushing U.N. Resolution 62/154, on "Combating defamation of religions," through the U.N. that would, if effectuated, have the West in fact adopt such blasphemy laws.
This challenge to freedom of speech world wide could not be any more insidious nor dangerous, both to us and the entire Muslim world. Yet Obama did not so much as mention it in his speech.
Obama, instead of addressing any of these issues head on in his Cairo address, did nothing more than restate the Wahhabi and Khomeinist propaganda - that Western modernity is at odds with Islam and that a good portion of Islam's problems arise out of the "colonialism" of "the West."
What Obama did was a a trick out of Psychology 101. It is a technique that he uses often. He articulates the complaints of his audience without judgment. This is effective because it leaves the audience with the belief that Obama understands their complaint and empathizes with it. But the downside of that technique is that, if it is not followed by some clearly articulated honesty, it simply reinforces in the audience that their complaints are valid. It is a superb technique for psychologists, mediators, and politicians campaigning for office. It is a dangerous tool indeed for a person charged with the responsibilities of leadership.
And instead of following his restatement with honesty, Obama followed with a recounting of Islamic achievements. They were many, and they were invaluable. They also occurred a millenium ago. What Obama needed to drive home was the honest and brutal truth - something akin to the following:
There was a time when Europeans, seeking enlightenment and learning, studied at the feet of Islamic scholars. It is a time long past but not forgotten, at least by those who seek to restore their lost Empire at any and all costs. Since its Golden Age during the Moorish Empire a millennium ago, Islamic history has been in an steady tailspin that has led to a culture of victimhood and death fueled by religious hatred, sectarian violence, centuries of isolation from Western enlightenment, and an overwhelming almost mystical desire to restore past glories. Today, the Arab world is constituted by a series of twenty-two failed states bereft, for the most part, of progressive leaders and unable to produce one single manufactured product that can compete on world markets. Far from being an enlightened civilization, it has become a cultural backwater replete with massive poverty, repressive governments, vast illiteracy, medieval laws, rising Islamist anger and a Gross Domestic Product less than that of . . . Spain. [It should not be that way. It need not be that way.]
Read the entire article.
The problem could not be any clearer. Nor could the solution. I wrote precisely on this topic on March 31, 2007 in response to the OIC's initial attack on Western freedom of speech. I repost that essay here:
____________________________________________________________
The reason we face the problem of radical Islam today is that, in its entire history, Islam has seen no Renaissance, no Reformation, no Period of Enlightenment. These titanic events in Western history led to the development of secular values that came out of, but were separate from, the Judeo-Christian religion that birthed them. And these events gradually took religion from the sphere of a government imposition and moved it into the realm of the individual and local community.
The Renaissance, the Reformation, and the Enlightenment were each developed through the process of critical thought - the questioning and challenging of religious ideals and dogma. It was this critical thought that allowed the West to seperate the wheat -- the belief in God and universal concepts of moral behavior -- from the chaff of religion – dogma that restricted development in all aspects of society: political, artistic, scientific, philosophical. Thus, today do our universities turn out the finest scientists, the finest writers, the finest mathematicians and astronomers, while the universities in Saudi Arabia primarily turn out Wahhabi clerics. And it is why the West leads the world in science and the arts while the morals police in Saudi Arabia hunt down sorcerers and the Saudi courts apply Wahhabi Sharia law to order the flogging of victims of gang rape.
There are seeds from which a Muslim Enlightenment could yet occur. They would require criticism and debate to take root. Yet these seeds are under mortal threat today from the growth of Wahhabi / Salafi Islam.
The seeds which would allow for an Enlightenment lie in Islam's earliest history. Year 1 to Muslims begins with Hijra, Mohammed’s emigration to Medina in 622 A.D. When Mohammed died, Islam was still largely confined to Arabia. It is important to note that, before Mohammed died, he left his followers with a concept most clearly stated in a hadith - an authenticated saying of Mohammed. That hadith provides that the ummah – the community of Muslims – can “never agree on an error.” Complimenting this in the Koran, it says “People, you order what is right, forbid what is wrong, and you believe in God.” (3:110)
These concepts, taken together, allow for the evolution of Islam. And in another critical development following Mohammed’s death, as Islam progressed, there came the concept of ijtihad (see here and here). Ijtihad is the practice of reasoning from the texts, the hadiths, the sunna and the works of scholars to determine what Islam should mean, what it should approve and disapprove. If there will ever be a moderation of Islam, it will come from those concepts of the hadith and the Koran mentioned above, and from the practice of ijtihad.
The remainder of Islam's history tells us why these seeds of an Enlightenment never took root. Following Mohammed’s death, Islam spread at a pace never before or since duplicated. Its rapid expansion – by the sword – continued almost unchecked for the next several hundred years. Actually, in this regard, for any Muslim to criticize the West as imperialistic is irony of the highest order. The West are pikers compared to the Islamic caliphates. Within 130 years following the Hijra, Arabic Muslims had conquered the Middle East, Turkey, all of North Africa, and the better part of Spain, and they were fighting battles inside France.
Through about 1100 A.D., Islamic society, led by the Arabs, far outshone the West in learning and technology. It was a far more enlightened society than what was to be found in Europe at the time. Indeed, at the turn of the first millenium, the premier city in the world was not London, Paris or Rome, but Baghdad. But, along with this vast expansion powered by the belief in Islamic destiny came the desire to control the precise nature of Islam by the Caliphs. At the end of the tenth century, the “gates of ijtihad” were ordered closed by the Caliphs and the Muslim philosophers cooperated. The concept of free reasoning fell from grace in Islam. This closing of the gates of ijtihad is credited by many scholars as the cause of the stagnation of Islam in succeeding centuries.
But there was much worse on the horizon. In the late 12th century came invasion by the Turks, followed closely by Ghengis Khan and the Mongol horde in the thirteenth century. For the Arabs, this was a catastrophe of titanic proportions. They were overrun, and it was the Turks, practitioners of Sufi Islam, not the Arabs, who emerged as the leadership of Islam. And into this time of turmoil was born Ibn Taymiya, the man whose philosophy and writings would be the foundation for Saudi Arabia’s Wahhabi Islam.
Taymiya started from the proposition that Islam was from God, and it was God’s intent that Islam should spread to the four corners of the earth. In this light, Taymiya saw the success of the Turk and Mongol conquers as a punishment from God because Arab Muslims had allowed Islam to be corrupted. His answer was to return to what he believed animated Islam at the time of Mohammed. He was puritanical and a literalist. The Islam he envisioned was one of absolute tenets – dogmatic and beyond questioning.
Fast forward to eighteenth century Arabia, where Ibn Wahhab was born. Wahhab embraced embraced the teachings of Taymiya and built upon them, arguing that any deviation therefrom was heretical and that the offender should be put to death. Wahhab promoted a triumphalist and imperialistic religion that saw anyone not in its membership as an enemy to be converted, conquered or killed. There has been little if any deviation from Wahhab's original dogma through to the modern day. Indeed, for example, one aspect of Wahhabi doctrine, taught in Saudi schools at least as recently as 2003, is that it is permissible to enslave “polytheists.” That comes from a Saudi textbook. If you are a Christian, by the way, you are a polytheist. Wahhabism is the soul of radical Islam. To go against any tenet of Wahhabi Islam is to conduct impermissible innovation and thus, to be labeled takfir, an unbeliever, – and subject to losing your head.
To continue with the chronology, Wahhab found his way to Najd, a backwater of Arabia controlled by tribe of the Sauds. Wahhab partnered with the Sauds and what followed, over the next two centuries, was an incredibly savage conquest of the Arabian peninsula by the House of Saud. And in each place they conquered, they imposed Wahhabi Islam.
Fast forward now to the 20th century. Two events of note occur. Turkey, home of Sufi Islam and the caliphate presiding over the majority of the Islamic world, came into World War I on the side of Germany and was ultimately defeated. Its Middle Eastern empire was divided up among the European counties. Attaturk took power in Turkey and divested Islam from politics, secularizing the country. This was, in essence, the first step towards a revolution in the Islamic world – the divorcing of religion from the nation state and limiting it to the private lives of Turkish citizens. Unfortunately, as time has gone on, Wahhabism has infected Turkey, and today we see the creep of Islamism into the state apparatus. Turkey has withdrawn from the precipice of a revolution to moderate and modernize Islam that its combination of secular government and classical Sufi Islam may have led.
The second event of note was the triumph of Wahhabi Islam with the conquest of Arabia by the House of Saud. Indeed, even before the final conquest, Wahhabi Islam had already influenced – or infected, if you like – many of the other schools of Islam. Two prime examples are the Pakistani Deobandi school that today is the basis for the Taliban, as well Islam in Egypt, from whence arose the first truly modern radical Islamist organization, the Muslim Brotherhood.
But Wahhabi Islam only truly became an engine of conquest with the growth of the oil industry and the influx of billions of petrodollars into Saudi Arabia. Saudi Arabia is spending these billions to spread its brand of Islam to the four corners of the world and to supplant the other schools of Islam. Other than oil, Saudi Arabia’s main exports are Wahhabi clerics, Wahhabi mosques, and Wahhabi schools to every corner of the world. Further, the petrodollars are used to fund the Middle East studies program at most major colleges in the Western World – whose teaching invariably cover, cover for, and cover up Wahhabi Islam – and to fund Wahhabi organizations such as CAIR that perform much the same function in Western society at large.
I do not know that Wahhabi Islam also influenced and radicalized Ayatollah Khoemeni. But, given that he took Iranian Shia Islam out of its historically nonpolitical role in Iran and thrust Shiaism, for the first time in history, into the political realm with the creation of Iran’s theocracy, I would suspect that it did. I would be absolutely amazed if some scholar did not eventually catalogue such an influence. (Update: See this from Francis Fukuyama in the WSJ making this connection)
To sum up, the whole of the Islamic world is endangered by the growth of Wahhabi Islam. And Wahhabi Islam holds it dogma to be beyond question – upon pain of censure or even death. If there is to be a moderation and modernization of Islam – a Reformation and Period of Enlightenment if you will – it will not will arise out of Wahhabi Islam without tremendous bloodshed.
Ultimately, in the world of ideas, it is only through questioning and critical reasoning that advancements occur. To put an Islamic face on that, it is only through the embrace of ijtihad and the concepts of Islam discussed earlier that there is any chance that Islam will finally see a great historical change to moderate and modernize from Wahhab’s vision of 7th century Islam into a form of Islam that can coexist with the rest of the world in the 21st century. And Western society has an obligation not to be coerced into silence, but to openly criticize what we find dangerous and wrong in Islam. If our voice is cowed, how can we expect the voice of would be moderates in the world of Islam to stand up - and withstand the inevitable Wahhabi onslaught to their existence. The cost to humanity and the world if Islam does not have its Reformation and Enlightenment will almost assuredly be apocalyptic.
Which brings us to today, and the United Nations Human Rights Organization. I have already posted that I believe the UN exists in an alternate Islamic universe. It finds fault with illegal acts or human rights violations only in Israel. See here and here. But we have now reached the final Islamic straw.
Friday, March 30, 2007, Islamic countries pushed through a resolution at the UN Human Rights Council demanding a global prohibition on the public defamation of religion. Lest there be any doubt about which religion they are concerned with, the only religion mentioned in the resolution is Islam. As stated in the minutes from the UN Human Rights Council meeting:
The Council expresses deep concern at attempts to identify Islam with terrorism, violence and human rights violations; notes with deep concern the intensification of the campaign of defamation of religions, and the ethnic and religious profiling of Muslim minorities, in the aftermath of the tragic events of 11 September 2001; urges States to take resolute action to prohibit the dissemination including through political institutions and organizations of racist and xenophobic ideas and material aimed at any religion or its followers that constitute incitement to racial and religious hatred, hostility or violence; also urges States to provide adequate protection against acts of hatred, discrimination, intimidation and coercion resulting from defamation of religions, to take all possible measures to promote tolerance and respect for all religions and their value systems and to complement legal systems with intellectual and moral strategies to combat religious hatred and intolerance; . . .
The UN is only doing the work of radical Wahhabi Islamists at this point. If there is ever to be a peaceful coexistence with Muslims, the West cannot gag itself as CAIR and the Islamists at UN would have us do. We can coexist with Muslims as long as they are not trying to kill us and impose their religion by coercion or by working fundamental changes to our Western secular values with ridiculous charges of Islamaphobia. Unfortunately, that is not the reality. Thus, it is their religion that needs to change. It needs to go through its Reformation, and there needs to be a period of Enlightenment. The clearest way to stop this transformation from ever occurring is to outlaw criticism of Islam. This would be putting a nail into the coffin of Western civilization, in addition to insuring the ultimate domination of the Wahhabi philosophy in Islam.
If this is what we can expect from UN as reformed, it needs to be defunded by the U.S. In the Senate hearings for his confirmation as the new U.S. Ambassador to the UN, Zalmay Khalilzad has argued against defunding the UN but has also stated that the UN faces a “mortal threat" if it fails to reform. There are no reforms on the horizon. It is time to allow the UN to subsist on Rials until it does.
_____________________________________________________
A truly brave man would have spoken honestly and would tried to use the bully pulpit to support reforms in Islam. Obama is not that person, and we are less safe for it.
Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History
Posted by
GW
at
Friday, June 05, 2009
0
comments
Labels: blasphemy, Cairo, colonialism, Islam, khomeinist, obama, OIC, Salafi, Tawfiq Hamid, terrorism, UN, Wahhabi
Obama's Cairo Address - A Walkback From Democracy and Iraq
No system of government can or should be imposed by one nation by any other. That does not lessen my commitment, however, to governments that reflect the will of the people. Each nation gives life to this principle in its own way, grounded in the traditions of its own people. America does not presume to know what is best for everyone, . . .
President Barack Obama, Cairo Address, June 4, 2009
Would it be possible for Obama to have made any clearer his repudiation of the democracy agenda - and by extension, his return to "real politik" whereby we will accept the tyrannical governments of the Middle East as we find them. Does Obama realize that doing precisely that is one of the central causes for anti-American sentiment in the Middle East. Perhaps he should listen to Michael Sheuer, who explains it in no undertain terms here. Or perhaps Condi Rice, who would tell him that:
For 60 years, . . . the United States, pursued stability at the expense of democracy in the [Middle East]. And we achieved neither. Now we are taking a different course. We are supporting the democratic aspirations of the people.
Indeed, to go one further, does Obama realize that it is the repressive regimes in the Middle East that provide the incubators for Islamic terrorists.
There are only two basic forms of government possible in this world, yet Obama disingenuously hides his retreat from promotion of democracy behind the canard that "each nation" gives expression to the will of the people in some unique way. That is utterly vacuous. Either you have an actual democracy with broad rights of sufferage or you have some form of tyranny. There are no other options. And history has taught us, if nothing else, that democracies, even rough and imperfect ones, have far greater long term stability and are far less aggressive than any form of tyranny.
What in fact we are seeing from Obama in his quotes above are multiculturalism and moral equivalence instead of discriminatory value judgments based on facts and history. According to Obama, all forms of government are apparently of equal value and, in "their own way," reflect the "will of the people." He is in dire need of a civics lesson it would seem. The history of the Middle East is not a history of "the will of the people" being manifest by their governments. To the contrary, its the history of tyrants and dictators, of brutal coups and blood in the streets. It is the history of a city in Syria leveled and its population erased. Its the history of chemical attacks on villages. It is the history of entire populations terrorized. It is anything but the "will of the people."
Indeed, there is only one country in the middle of the Middle East that truly reflects, today, the "will of the people." It is the nascent democracy in Iraq. And instead of talking that up and stoking the fires of freedom, Obama quite literally ignored Iraq during his speech, but to announce that, in accordance with his high moral standards, he would abandon Iraq by 2012. Iraq is a beacon of hope to many oppressed people, not the least of whom is numbered the people of Iran. Yet to Obama, for purely partisan reasons, it is an experiment better forgotten, and the sooner the better.
And unfortunately, Obama has decided to cease promoting democracy just when it seems to be taking hold over the repressive ideologies of the Islamic parties throughout the Middle East. That was the subject of a recent WSJ article, discussing not merely the gains of secular parties at the polls, but the gains of women in free and fair elections.
Only one nation in the Middle East must be truly happy with Obama's walkback of democracy and walk away from Iraq. That country is Iran. As I've point out many times before, Iraq, because of its democracy, because of its secular Shia government, and because of its adherence to the traditional Shia concept of quietism, poses a mortal threat to Iran. Yet now Obama has virtually declared open season on Iraq in a time certain. And indeed, given his stated unwillingness to "impose" a government on any country, that logic also dictates that Obama would not intervene to stop the morphing of any government from one form to another. Thus if Iran succeeds short of open warfare in changing Iraq's government to align with its own, they can have a reasonable expectation that it will elicit no response from President Obama.
And a final world must be said about one other country today in the Middle East that must have been incredibly sorry to hear Obama's speech. Lebanon - a country with an imperfect democracy, but a country on the verge of losing even that. Lebanon's Cedar Revolution brought a fragile democratic government to power. And Iran yet again stands by, looking to break that government and ensconce their proxy, Hezbollah, into power. They are spending masses of money in the upcoming election. And what hope has Obama given to the people of Lebanon? He ignored them. With Iran practically occupying the country and Obama ignoring it, they can have no hope.
Obama's faux moralizing, his reliance on multicultural ethos, and his failure to see the importance of promoting democracy in the Middle East virtually assures dark days ahead. Those days are dark both for the people living under tyrannical rule and for us.
Summary - Obama's Cairo Address: What We Needed, What We Got
Part 1 - Obama's Cairo Address: Hiding From The Existential Problems Of The Muslim World
Part 2 - Obama's Cairo Address: A Walk Back From Democracy & Iraq
Part 3 - Obama's Cairo Address: Obama Calls For Women's Rights While Glossing Over Discrimination & Violence
Part 4 - Obama's Cairo Address: Nukes, Iran & Weakness Writ Large
Part 5 - Obama's Cairo Address: Israel & Palestine – A Little Good, A Lot Of Outrageousness
Part 6 - Obama's Cairo Address: Islam's Tradition Of Religious Tolerance?
Part 7 - Obama's Cairo Address: The Dangerous Whitewashing Of History
Posted by
GW
at
Friday, June 05, 2009
0
comments
Labels: Condi Rice, Democracy, democracy promotion, Hezbollah, Iran, Iraq, Lebanon, Michael Scheuer, middle east, obama





